Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bill Heath's avatar

I am now feeling hopelessly ignorant. It strikes me that libraries are always political. What to include, what to exclude, what to emphasize, how to make access easier and more inviting to everyone. Each of these decisions has a liberal answer as well as an authoritarian answer.

I encountered this in a slightly different setting about seventeen or eighteen years ago. Our family has been close to another family, whose daughters consider me a second father, just as our daughters consider the family's husband and wife to be a second set of parents. One day my great friend Jane called me with a complaint about the reading list for her youngest daughter, then about 15. It included a book with a (gasp!) gay character, and another in which a character was murdered. I agreed with her, and suggested the schools return to teaching the classics, such as MacBeth, Oedipus Rex, the writings of Aristotle. She agreed whole-heartedly.

Then I reminded her what the story of Oedipus entailed. She was struck dumb.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts