10 Comments

what I found interesting was how much good handwriting was valued before printing.

Expand full comment

Yes, it is amazing how handwriting was valued. Now it seems to be completely ignored even in schools. which is unfortunate.

Expand full comment

To think they used his handwriting when printing began. All those nuns that stressed handwriting must have been thinking of Poggio.

Expand full comment

Ah I remember enjoying The Swerve. Such a great story.

Expand full comment

Back to Herculaneum for a sec.

I didn't mention that in the Wikipedia article, there is also a discussion of artwork that has been found there. There are busts, sculptures, and frescoes, It must have been quite a place.

In my comment, I meant to say: "The losses of the human RECORD are so consistent..."

The human record also varies. It will take a 21st century (I do hope) to reconstruct the library but we have these busts. What a wonder.

Am I really looking at Scipio Africanus? Isn't that something to ponder. Dour looking guy, Great general but he sure had his enemies so, if it is him, are we getting a look at his soul? Artists do that kind of thing.

Expand full comment

Related news.

AI reads text from ancient Herculaneum scroll for the first time

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-03212-1

This is such exciting news. The losses of the human are so consistent and dispiriting that such stories are rare and welcome. Just maybe...maybe...this library can now be reconstructed.

Some years ago, I collected links about this library. I had five and two are left. I can't document this statement right now but it is accurate and gives the gist of the importance of this news:

"It was believed possible that, as "classics professor David Armstrong of the University of Texas-Austin said 'If you were going to recover all the lost literary works of antiquity in one place, this is your best chance.'"

One of those references is still available and gives a view of what was known in 2002:

Robert Harris, "Ancient Roman villa may hold world's richest literary treasure"

The Age (theage.com.au), April 2, 2002

http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2002/04/01/1017206183365.html

Wikipedia's entry has more detail and more recent information about what has been happening in the last 20 years. Note the links to the Herculaneum Society. There is also a book now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Villa_of_the_Papyri

It is what I called at one time "The Miracle of Herculaneum." Here's hoping.

Expand full comment

I have made notes to follow up on this! Thank you Dr.Data.

Expand full comment

A very Nice blog on one of my favorite books!

thank you.

Expand full comment

Thank you so much. After I read Swerve I tried to make it interesting. Then I found the lecture online because the book is SO MUCH MORE (as you know) then I could summarize.

Expand full comment

Handwriting is still valued in some cultures, for example in China. while I was in Beijing for the IFLA Conference in 1996, a reception clerk came up to my hotel room to ask me to sign my name properly. My illegible scrawl was not acceptable.

Expand full comment