Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Koshmarov's avatar

Even though they're performative, I still feel that these gestures are meaningful in some way insofar as they acknowledge historical wrongdoing -- although it doesn't help the dead. King Willem-Alexander (b. 1967) is in no way personally responsible for the depredations of the Dutch Empire (when it existed), yet as the living embodiment of the Dutch state he feels compelled to apologize. It's like the old Welsh sin-eater tradition, in a way. It must be weird and annoying to be a monarch in the modern world.

I will be glad to be contradicted, but I am fairly sure no U.S. president has apologized to any other country for American acts of aggression. The closest we are going to get is probably U.S. Grant:

"For myself," Grant wrote later about the United States war against Mexico, "I was bitterly opposed to the measure, and to this day regard the war, which resulted, as one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation."

https://www.army.mil/article/216806/grant_in_mexico_one_of_the_most_unjust_wars_ever_waged

Expand full comment
elm's avatar

"The persbreidel also enabled the Dutch to prevent publications that might antagonize Japan after Japan's military incursion into China, especially anti-Japanese sentiment among Chinese in Indonesia."

And now it's corporate edicts against the wrong sort of writing about China.

"Port cities such as Jakarta (named Batavia 1619–1942) were seen as hotbeds for the spread of nationalism and opposition to Dutch imperialism. The Dutch government attempted to secure power through maritime policing networks, close collaboration with British and French surveillance entities ashore, and by segregation on ships, meant to 'teach' those on board their position within imperial hierarchies. The prohibition on publishing press offences (persdelict) articles were added to the Dutch colony's Penal Code in 1914. These were articles that expressed or instigated feelings of hostility, hatred, or contempt against the Netherlands— writers could be jailed for up to seven years."

...not to mention the recurrent trend of the elites of one country hooking up with the elites of another country (often previously sworn enemies) to control their respective populations.

elm

freedom for who, exactly?

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts