Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bill Heath's avatar

Students who defaced it in 2018 will either deeply regret their actions in 2038, or will be making rules for the rest of us about what we are allowed to like and read. And will not know a single person who sees Kipling's work as art, and think that's just fine. I pity them.

Expand full comment
Tim Roessler's avatar

Too bad the so-called students who vandalized "If" didn't read the poems Kipling wrote after his son died in World War I. Or, "Gods of the Copybook Headings." Kipling -- as usual -- is a much more complicated figure than his caricature. In "Stalky and Company", for example, the students refuse to salute the Union Jack -- at the height of Victorian Imperialism. More people who made policy for Afghanistan should have read "The Once and Future King." Not only are these great stories with wonderful entrancing narratives but, gee, you learn some things about the world you may not have known. And about Kipling as a writer. People lose a lot by not actually reading good writers, even unfashionable ones. On a side note, Hopper sneaked some of "If" into Apocalypse Now. He must have been obsessed with the poem.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts