22 Comments
User's avatar
Boris Petrov's avatar

Thank you, Kathleen -- "it is going to be over..."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4BuMaGlKp0 -- “Democracy Now” – Feb 15, 2023

Reporter Seymour Hersh on "How America Took Out the Nord Stream Pipeline": Exclusive TV Interview

• Feb. 16 -- Flash: Sy Hersh on Democracy Now -- "It's going to be over."

https://silentpartner.substack.com/p/flash-sy-hersh-on-democracy-now

• Feb. 15 - Of Limited Hangouts -- Of the arts of distraction and obfuscation.

https://silentpartner.substack.com/p/of-limited-hangouts

• Feb 11 -- Three on Sy -- This will only get more intense.

https://silentpartner.substack.com/p/three-on-sy

• Feb 10 -- Blackout! They don't want you to know. https://silentpartner.substack.com/p/blackout

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

Sy Hersh was right on Vietnam and right about torture in Iraq so I think he should be listened to on this.

Expand full comment
Mari, the Happy Wanderer's avatar

I agree too. Elif Batuman has an excellent article on a recent New Yorker about Pushkinpad and efforts to ban Russian books. Rereading Russian Classics in the Shadow of the Ukraine Warhttps://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/01/30/rereading-russian-classics-in-the-shadow-of-the-ukraine-war

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

Thank you. I will go to the library for this one.

Expand full comment
Adele Fasick's avatar

Great article calling our attention to what's going on. I'm going to look for that New Yorker article. Why do people keep coming back to the practice of banning books? It's a terrible idea and has never really worked--no matter how difficult the language problems may be.

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

In the interview that is translated in this blog post the Ukrainian Library director was calling on the world to ban Russian books. I wonder if she would agree that Tolstoy's pacifism is worthy of saving?

Expand full comment
Koshmarov's avatar

wild stuff. It's weird how intense cultural extremism seems to have become a default, or at least the default that merits broadcasting.

isn't the whole point of libraries/archives to provide a (hopefully) permanent bulwark against ephemeral crazes? preaching to the choir, i know

Expand full comment
Koshmarov's avatar

It always tells you more about the would-be banner than the attempted banned, n'est-ce pas?

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

It didn't work for the Catholic Church, either.

Expand full comment
Erin E.'s avatar

Love the last quote 😂👏🏼

Expand full comment
Koshmarov's avatar

Böök is a hell of a name

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

He is a Library advocate from Finland. The Finnish word for book is Kirja--but yes, I wish his was my name.

Expand full comment
Koshmarov's avatar

You're only 3 consonants and a couple of diaëreses away!

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

Great catch!

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

I made a mistake--the original is in Norwegian, not Finnish. I fixed this on the permanent Substack post. Our overseas correspondents have so much linguistic ability.

Expand full comment
Bill Heath's avatar

It helps to look at Norwegian, Finnish, Czech and German as a four-team sports league engaged in non-stop trades of letters and diacritical marks. Czech is mostly a Slavic language, but the Czechs (and Slovaks) are both allergic to vowels. Finns suffer from a rare deficiency of vowels. German is an aggressive language, which fights to take over other languages, such as Nederlands, Schwitzer Deutch, Schwaebische, Bayerisch, Danish, Icelandic, Norwegian and others. Norwegian is spoken by nine people, most of whom live in igloos and row long boats across the ocean. Recently, Czech tried to trade its last three "I's" to Norwegian for two growls, a spit, and a diacritial mark to be named later.

And here we are.

Expand full comment
Kathleen McCook's avatar

What do you call someone who speaks 3 languages? --trilingual

What do you call someone who speaks 2 languages? -bilingual

What do you call someone who speaks 1 language?-American

What do you call someone who speaks all these?-Bill H.

Expand full comment
Mari, the Happy Wanderer's avatar

I lived in Prague for four years and used to be able to speak and write intermediate Czech. It was a continual aggravation to me that the iPhone doesn’t have a háček for the e or n or an acute accent for the y, all of which are needed quite frequently when writing Czech!

Expand full comment
Bill Heath's avatar

I dealt with Czechs and a few Slovaks in the 1980s whom I recruited to work for us. One of my most important recruits was a Slovak who had information about a Soviet-gauge railway that ended in a camouflage building, 200 kilometers closer to the German border than we had known to exist. Soviet-gauge railways could not travel on Western-gauge tracks, and tanks had to be carried on rail cars to reach the West.

Fortunately, the only time I visited Prague, in 2005, I was able to get by on English and German. Prague was established by Germans.

Expand full comment
Mari, the Happy Wanderer's avatar

Very cool story! I lived in Prague from 2014–18, and by then most people’s second language was English, but older people tended to have German for a second language.

Expand full comment
Koshmarov's avatar

In my limited experience, the Czechs have the Germans' good points but are just generally nicer? Prague is a "walkable city" because motorists actually give pedestrians the right of way, unlike Washington DC.

Expand full comment
Mari, the Happy Wanderer's avatar

This is true! Drivers respect pedestrians, and not just in no-traffic zones. Amazing. And I agree with you that Czech people are nice. Before we moved there, I was warned that Czechs would be chilly and standoffish, but nothing could be further from the truth. I also love the libertarian attitudes you’d see in Prague. Smoke dope on the street? Whatever. You do you. It was a lovely place to live.

Expand full comment